How Zero Escape Fills in AI: The Somnium Files’ Biggest Plot Hole

AI: The Somnium Files is a cyberpunk detective story about an amnesic cop with an AI implanted in his left eye. Over the course of his investigations, he makes use of a special machine that lets him and his AI partner interact directly with a suspect’s subconscious—using dream logic to uncover the secrets others try to keep hidden. While it is a solid murder mystery visual novel with several branching paths, there is one aspect that is never really explored—the deus ex machina that makes the true ending possible.

[This article contains major spoilers for both AI: The Somnium Files and the Zero Escape series of games.]

On several paths through AI: The Somnium Files, you reach a dead end that prevents you from continuing and asks you to return later. Then, by playing through the other routes of the story, you learn key pieces of information that allow you to return to those dead ends and progress further.

There’s just one strange thing about this. Each route through the story is literally a separate timeline—a different way that Date’s investigation could have gone. Our detective hero has no way of directly communicating between timelines—nor does he know really that they even exist. Thus there should be no way for the vital information to transfer from one Date to another.

Image source: Spike Chunsoft, Inc. on Twitter

Early on, the game gives an explanation for how this is possible: that by making changes inside a person’s mind Date is able to shift between realities. However, this is later revealed to be a red herring—Date was going full sci-fi in his attempt to figure out how a person who he saw dead was suddenly alive again. (There was, in fact, a perfectly mundane explanation to the seemingly miraculous resurrection.)

Later in the game, Saito suggests that all Date is doing is remembering things he learned before his amnesia. However, both we and Date know right away that this explanation doesn’t hold water: Date’s memories are definitely things he experienced in parallel timelines.

In the end, the mystery of how Date is able to remember events and knowledge from other timelines is simply left unexplained… well, in this game anyway.

Image source: Aksys Games on Twitter

AI: The Somnium Files is written and directed by Kotaro Uchikoshi, the man behind the Zero Escape series of games. Like with AI: The Somnium Files, Zero Escape weaves its separate timelines into a single cohesive narrative—one where the gameplay design choice of letting you jump back and forth between the game’s different routes at will is likewise a major plot point. So, given that both stories share a writer and the same thing seems to be happening, it’s not a stretch to assume that the rules of timeline-hopping are the same between both works. And while AI: The Somnium Files doesn’t explain how sending information between realities is possible, Zero Escape most certainly does.

The explanation found in Zero Escape is based on Rupert Sheldrake’s pseudoscientific “Morphogenetic Field” theory—namely the idea that “shapes of living organisms and their behavioral patterns are transmitted through a field not visible to the eye.”


Image source: Aksys Games on Twitter

In the Zero Escape series, certain characters are able to access the Morphogenetic Field instinctively in moments of great stress and danger. These people are known as ESPers. Some are only able to send information across the Morphogenetic Field while others are only able to receive it. However, with continued use of these powers through life and death situations, some ESPers are able to become SHIFTers that are able to send their own consciousnesses both across time and into alternate realities—though only into their own bodies.

Now, this doesn’t necessarily mean that a person’s entire mind is transferred between timelines. In fact, only the most powerful of SHIFTers with tons of practice are able to achieve this. Much more commonly, it’s only a single word or phrase—a flash of memory—that makes the jump. And if that sounds familiar, it’s because this is exactly what Date is experiencing in AI: The Somnium Files.

Date is perhaps the weakest SHIFTer we’ve seen in Uchikoshi’s work—and he’s further hampered by the fact that he doesn’t have another ESPer around to explain to him what is going on. However, going through numerous life-or-death struggles as a detective has allowed him to subconsciously send vital information from tragedy-filled timelines to those where there’s still a shot at a happy ending.

Image source: Kotaro Uchikoshi Eng on Twitter

All this makes you wonder if, despite Zero Escape appearing to be a game within the game, that AI: The Somnium Files is actually a Zero Escape side story. Perhaps the newly announced AI: THE SOMNIUM FILES – nirvanA Initiative will feature a mention or two about an all-too-familiar gas mask glad terrorist and their band of ESPers trying to bring down a religious zealot bent on causing a genocidal nuclear war.

Or perhaps we’ll just get another solid cyberpunk mystery. I’m not going to complain either way.

AI: The Somnium Files was released on September 17, 2019 for PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, and PC.


Top image source: Spike Chunsoft, Inc. on Twitter.

Become a patron at Patreon!
Richard Eisenbeis Written by:

One Comment

  1. Marcus
    November 16, 2021
    Reply

    One of the best story I have ever played, I got hook! I can’t unravel the twist. I hope they make this a movie and make zero escape a series

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *